I can see why Dylan might like Jeter. They both have something in common:
I'll tell you why I don't like Derek Jeter. Jeter is just a sum of his parts. I don't like fade hair cuts. I don't like guys that everybody likes, how can you trust somebody like that?
I like the guys that are imperfect, that have something to overcome. All Jeter has ever done is succeed. That's a boring story. I like the guy who may be the greatest singles hitter of all time who can't control his weight. Now that is a story!