I was going to throw it out there that we could debate whether or not baseball should finally sack up and implement instant replay, but I found a Jayson Stark chat where he debated the same thing and now I'm even more convinced that there should be replay, so I'm hardly going to be a neutral party. At the same time, I can play devil's advocate as well as anybody, and I don't have much to say right now regarding the Padres so I'll open it up.
Should there be instant replay in baseball? If you think no, explain yourself! If you think yes, give a reasonable suggestion for how it would be implemented.
GO INSTANT REPLAY!!!